A 97-Year-Old Cardinal Survived Torture and Communism. His Secret Was Not Willpower.

Enver Hoxha's Albania declared itself the world's first atheist state in 1967 and proceeded to execute priests, ban religious observance, and imprison anyone who continued to practice. The program assumed that if every external reinforcement of religious belief (community, ritual, symbol, clergy) were removed, the belief itself would dissolve. Simoni's 18 years demonstrated the assumption was false. He did not stop believing. He did not stop celebrating Mass. He did not stop forgiving.

Cardinal Ernest Simoni, now 97, was arrested in communist Albania for exercising his priesthood and condemned to death. The sentence was commuted; he served 18 years in prison, and after his 1981 release was still treated as an "enemy of the people," forced into further labor in mines and sewers until the regime fell in 1990. He never renounced his faith. He forgave his torturers. Asked by the National Catholic Register what advice he'd give those facing persecution today, he answered: "Love your enemies; pray for your friends." Elsewhere in the same conversation, reflecting on why suffering for Christ is bearable at all, he said simply: "with Jesus everything is beautiful."[^1]

These are not the words of a man who survived on willpower alone. The question worth pressing is what actually held.

What the dark night does to a person

Jordan Aumann's Spiritual Theology transmits the teaching of John of the Cross: the passive purifications, the dark nights of sense and spirit, are the means by which God strips a soul of self-reliance so that love, not personal effort, becomes the sustaining force.[^2] Aumann quotes John of the Cross directly: "However assiduously the beginner in mortification exercises himself in all these actions and passions, he can never completely succeed, far from it, until God shall effect it in him passively by means of the purgation of said night."[^2] No quantity of active ascetical effort produces the transformation that uncontrollable suffering accomplishes. The ego's project of self-construction collapses, and what remains is ordered to something beyond the self.

Simoni's account fits this pattern with a precision that deserves attention. He celebrated Mass clandestinely using a can lid as a paten. He held the Eucharist at the center of his existence while the Albanian state worked to dismantle every external support for that existence. The regime could seize his vestments, his parish, his freedom, his body. It could not locate the act of the will directed toward God, because that act does not reside in any condition the state controls.

Why charity cannot be coerced

This is what Aquinas argued in the Summa Theologiae. As Aumann summarizes it: "Charity is a supernatural habit infused by God into the will, by which we love God for himself above all things."[^3] Charity, as an infused habit seated in the will and directed toward God as its proper object, is not a property of external conditions. Torture can destroy a body. Forced labor can exhaust a nervous system. Solitary confinement can fracture ordinary psychological functioning. Charity, located in the will and sustained by grace, operates in a register none of these coercions can reach.

The anthropological failure

The Albanian regime's failure was not merely political; it was anthropological. Marxist-Leninist programs operated on a materialist account of the person in which consciousness, motivation, and identity are products of economic and social conditions. Change the conditions radically enough, the theory holds, and the person changes with them. Imprison a priest, deny him sacraments, subject him to years of hard labor, and the priestly identity should dissolve into the conditions.

Craig Steven Titus, Paul C. Vitz, and William J. Nordling, in their account of the Catholic Christian Meta-Model of the Person, ground human dignity in the created soul, distinguishing basic dignity from anything conferred by the state or by social position.[^4] A model that locates personhood in social and economic conditions predicts that Simoni should have broken. The CCMMP predicts he would not break at the level of a will ordered to God, and he did not. Material self-interest, the only motive the materialist framework could fully credit, pointed unmistakably toward compliance. That Simoni refused, and went on refusing across 18 years, was unintelligible within the terms of communist anthropology. Within Catholic anthropology, it was intelligible: charity, seated in the will and directed toward its proper object, does not become less operative because the body is suffering.

The shape of charity under maximum pressure

Dietrich Bonhoeffer, writing in The Cost of Discipleship from within his own experience of a totalitarian state, pressed the logic of enemy-love to its structural conclusion: "Through the medium of prayer we go to our enemy, stand by his side, and plead for him to God."[^5] His framing of enemy-love as vicarious intercession, bearing the enemy's condition before God, maps directly onto Simoni's counsel. "Love your enemies; pray for your friends" is not a softening of the demand. It is the full demand, stated in the compressed form of a man who lived it.

Simoni's forgiveness of his torturers is an act of the will directed toward the good of persons who had tried to destroy him, not the product of emotional resolution or psychological processing.

'With Jesus everything is beautiful'

Read against this background, Simoni's phrase is not an aesthetic comment.[^1] It is the testimony of a man for whom beauty was a structural reality: the order of a life directed toward its proper end, which remained beautiful even when the conditions were a mine shaft or a sewer. The communist program could produce compliance, exhaustion, recantation. It could not produce a 97-year-old cardinal who greets visitors with forgiveness and tells sufferers that everything is beautiful anyway.

The Catholic Christian account of the person, grounded in a created soul whose dignity no regime confers and whose will can be oriented toward a good no coercion reaches, predicted Simoni's survival where the materialist alternative could not. The task for those working at the intersection of faith and human flourishing is to hold that account with the same fidelity Simoni held the Eucharist on a can lid: as something real, structural, and worth protecting at cost.

References

[^1]: Pentin, E. (2026, July 17). 97-year-old 'living martyr' cardinal, who forgave his torturers: 'Love your enemies; pray for your friends.' National Catholic Register. https://www.ncregister.com/interview/cardinal-simoni-interview (Interview conducted June 28, 2026.)

[^2]: Aumann, J. (1980). Spiritual theology. Sheed & Ward. (Chapter on passive purifications, citing John of the Cross, The Dark Night, Book I.)

[^3]: Aumann, J. (1980). Spiritual theology. Sheed & Ward. (Chapter on charity, treating Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 23.)

[^4]: Titus, C. S., Vitz, P. C., & Nordling, W. J. (2020). Created in the image of God. In P. C. Vitz, W. J. Nordling, & C. S. Titus (Eds.), A Catholic Christian meta-model of the person: Integration with psychology and mental health (Chapter 17). Divine Mercy University Press.

[^5]: Bonhoeffer, D. (1959). The cost of discipleship (R. H. Fuller, Trans.). Macmillan. (Chapter on the Sermon on the Mount, section on loving enemies.)